Is there contradiction in Islam?

Is there contradiction in Islam?

There are many numerical contradictions in the Quran. Similar mistakes you can see in the verse: Quran 4: 11 – 12, and Quran 4: 176 in inheritance law.

Are there contradictions in Sahih Bukhari?

It has nothing to do with the lofty personality of the noble Messenger of Allah. However, it has been said earlier in a related question that Sahih Bukhari just like other Hadith books in the Muslim world is not hundred percent free of errors, contradictions and interpolations.

Why hadith contradicts the Quran?

They contradict the Quran because the hadiths are the alleged sayings of Mohammed, we don’t know if he said these things, even if ghe did, they could, not know Allah told him to say them,, they heard him, and hjust blindly believed him.

Is there any mistake in the Quran?

Islam is built on the never proved claim that the Quran is the exact words of a god. But no omniscient god uses wrong facts, other errors, contradictions, etc., by the hundreds and more. There is much discrepancy in the Quran = the Quran is not from a god = Islam is a made up “religion”. See also verse 4/82.

Is the Quran unchanged?

Many Muslims say, “The Quran is the most authentic religious book in existence. The first Qurans ever compiled still do exist and they are all identical. The Quran remains unchanged ever since its inception over 1400 ago.”

Does the hadith contradict the Quran?

It is proven above that sahih hadith can contradict the Quran. If the example sahih hadith above contradict the Quran, that proves that they are unreliable and therefore other sahih hadith could also be unreliable, even though they are labeled as “sahih”.

Is it haram to not follow hadith?

Originally Answered: Is it okay for a Muslim to not believe in Hadith? Yes, it is completely okay unless you want to be a cultural Muslim. God surely told us to obey the messenger, but by accepting the Quran. The Book has his sayings and Allah is protecting them.

Can hadith be wrong?

Hadith can not be wrong. What can go wrong is people created some narrations and claimed these as hadith. That is forgery! Ancient Islamic scholars had done their best to sift the wheat(authentic saying of the Prophet) from the tares(fabricated sayings) by proper methodology.

Was the original Quran burned?

There are Qur’an cemeteries. So, the “Original Qur’an” (there were few original copies, which is a whole other topic), was not burned, but buried somewhere.

Is Quran written by Allah?

The Quran (/kʊrˈɑːn/, kuurr-AHN; Arabic: القرآن al-Qurʼān [alqurˈʔaːn], “the recitation”), also romanized Qur’an or Koran, is the central religious text of Islam, believed by Muslims to be a revelation from God (Allah)….Quran.